Naman Shrestha
When 9-year-old Jessica Marie Lunsford was found dead two weeks after her disappearance, it left the entire community shell-shocked while her loved ones went into a state of grief. As the investigators closed in on the perpetrator responsible for the brutal murder, they learned that he had already been convicted of crimes in the past. The episode titled ‘The Boogeyman’ of Investigation Discovery’s ‘People Magazine Investigates’ delves deep into the murder case of Jessica through exclusive interviews with her loved ones and the officials linked to the investigation.
Jessica Marie Lunsford’s Remains Were Found in a Shallow Grave Weeks After She Went Missing
On October 6, 1995, in Dellview, North Carolina, Jessica Marie Lunsford entered the world of Mark Allan Lunsford and Angela Bryant in the form of a little bundle of joy. When she was about a year old, her parents unfortunately got divorced as their marriage had deteriorated over the years. Later, she remarried another man and became a mother to an adorable son. After the divorce, Jessica stayed with his father and grandparents at their Homosassa, Florida, residence. With a promising future ahead of her, her parents and other loved ones were excited to see her achieve success in life. Unfortunately, fate had other ideas.
In the early morning hours of February 24, 2005, 9-year-old Jessica suddenly vanished from her bedroom. Despite filing a missing persons report, the police could not find any trace of the missing girl for nearly a month. Finally, on March 19, her family and friends’ worst nightmare became reality as the detectives found Jessica’s remains buried in a plastic bag about 150 yards away from her residence in a densely wooded area. Upon examining the body, it was reported that it had undergone moderate to severe decomposition. As for the cause of her death, it was determined to be due to suffocation caused by the lack of oxygen inside the plastic bag. In light of this discovery, a homicide investigation was launched with the aim of getting to the bottom of the case and bringing the killer to justice.
Someone From the Neighborhood Was Responsible For the Murder of Jessica
During the investigation prior to finding Jessica’s body, the detectives came across a property that was just 65 yards away from her house. Upon digging deeper into it, they learned that the owner, John Evander Couey, had an extensive rap sheet and was a convicted child sex offender. Thus, on March 12, 2005, John was taken into custody in August, Georgia, and brought in for questioning regarding Jessica’s disappearance. In his interview, he claimed that he had no hand in the disappearance of the nine-year-old girl and that the reason for his move to Georgia was solely work-related.
With nothing direct or incriminating to connect him to the disappearance, the police had no choice but to release him after the interview. However, the investigators found a break in the case a couple of days later as the suspect’s half-sister, Dorothy Dixon, allowed them to comb through her Homosassa trailer, where John used to live with her and her family. On March 14, the detectives found his and Jessica’s DNA on a blood-stained mattress found inside his closet. Thus, with enough evidence against him, the authorities arrested and charged him with the murder of Jessica Lunsford on March 17 before transporting him to the Citrus County jail in Florida.
During his interview on March 18, 2005, John confessed to kidnapping, sexually assaulting, and killing Jessica Lunsford. He claimed that on the fateful night, he only planned to rob the Lunsford house. However, when he sneakily entered the house, Jessica woke up and saw him. According to him, he somehow managed to convince her to follow him out of the house, after which he took her to the trailer he stayed at and raped her multiple times in his bedroom. As per his claims, he kept her alive for three days after kidnapping her before burying her alive inside plastic bags in the nearby wooded area. However, this confession proved to be inadmissible in court because he was not granted a lawyer despite his requests to get one.
John Couey Was Brought to Justice But Passed Away Before the Sentences Were Carried Out
In early 2007, John Evander Couey stood trial for the killing of 9-year-old Jessica Marie Lunsford. The prosecution presented several incriminating pieces of evidence against the defendant, including his and her DNA on the mattress as well as her fingerprints in his closet. After a few weeks of arguments between the defense and prosecution in front of the jury and judge, on March 7, 2007, the jury returned with a guilty verdict and convicted John of all the charges against him, including first-degree murder, burglary with assault or battery upon any person, capital sexual battery, and kidnapping.
After a week, the jury reached a decision and recommended the convict receive the death sentence. However, the case was appealed by the defense, and on August 11, 2007, the defense argued that John had suffered emotional abuse for many years of his life and had an IQ less than normal. Upon testing his IQ with the most credible intelligence, his IQ was rated at 78, which was above the accepted level of intellectual disability. Thus, on August 24, 2007, John Couey received the death sentence, in addition to three consecutive life terms for his crimes in relation to the murder of Jessica Lunsford. However, more than a couple of years later, on September 30, 2009, the killer died of natural causes.
Read More: Cristina Prodan Murder: Where is Joseph Porter Now?
