10 Documentaries Like American Nightmare You Must See

In the documentary ‘American Nightmare,’ the gripping narrative unfolds after a traumatic home invasion and kidnapping in 2015. The focus is on Denise Huskins and Aaron Quinn, a couple accused of orchestrating the incident when Huskins unexpectedly reappears. Initially dubbed the ‘real-life Gone Girl’ case, the series delves into the events surrounding the couple’s awakening to a masked intruder in the middle of the night. Huskins is subsequently kidnapped for ransom, only to be released 48 hours later.

This three-part Netflix docuseries goes beyond a mere recounting of facts, incorporating new interviews and interrogation footage. It examines not only the specifics of the case but also the broader implications of society’s insatiable appetite for true crime and the allure of villain narratives. The cast includes Denise Huskins, Aaron Quinn, and Henry Lee. If your true crime cravings keep you hungry for more, here are 10 documentaries like ‘American Nightmare’ that you should consider checking out.

10. Crime Scene: The Vanishing at the Cecil Hotel (2021)

In the documentary ‘Crime Scene: The Vanishing at the Cecil Hotel,’ the haunting exploration of Elisa Lam’s disappearance intertwines with the eeriness of the Cecil Hotel. Just as in ‘American Nightmare,’ this true-crime series dissects a perplexing case—Lam’s mysterious vanishing in 2013. The narrative unfolds with a combination of real footage, interviews, and archival material, echoing the chilling atmosphere of ‘American Nightmare.’

Both documentaries not only unravel the details of the cases but also delve into the broader societal fascination with true crime. Directed by Joe Berlinger, ‘Crime Scene: The Vanishing at the Cecil Hotel’ grips viewers with a similar intensity, examining the complexities surrounding Lam’s unsettling disappearance and the infamous hotel’s dark history.

9. Amanda Knox (2016)

The documentary ‘Amanda Knox,’ directed by Rod Blackhurst and Brian McGinn, examines the 2007 murder case in Italy, where American student Amanda Knox was accused of killing her roommate. The film delves into the legal proceedings, media sensationalism, and Knox’s eventual acquittal. Similarly to ‘American Nightmare,’ it navigates a complex true-crime narrative involving accusations and a scrutinized legal process. Both documentaries explore the impact of media portrayal, public perception, and the quest for justice in high-profile cases, shedding light on the intricate dynamics surrounding sensationalized crimes and the individuals thrust into the spotlight.

8. Victim/Suspect (2023)

Directed by Nancy Schwartzman, ‘Victim/Suspect’ explores the alarming phenomenon of young women charged with making false rape accusations despite their honesty. The documentary, akin to ‘American Nightmare,’ unravels a disturbing reality within the legal system. Journalist Rachel de Leon, from The Center for Investigative Reporting, uncovers a nationwide pattern of cases where victims become suspects, highlighting the complexities and injustices surrounding false accusations. Both documentaries shed light on the precarious intersection of law and truth, emphasizing the need for a nuanced understanding of crime narratives and the consequences of societal expectations on those involved.

7. Who Took Johnny (2014)

‘Who Took Johnny’ is a documentary directed by David Beilinson, Suki Hawley, and Michael Galinsky. It dives into the mysterious disappearance of Johnny Gosch, a 12-year-old paperboy who vanished in 1982. Through interviews and investigations, it uncovers disturbing facets of child abduction and explores Johnny’s mother’s relentless quest for answers. Similar to ‘American Nightmare,’ it grips audiences with a real-life, unsettling narrative involving a disappearance, sparking questions about truth, justice, and the societal fascination with true crime. Both documentaries unveil the harrowing aftermath of traumatic events and the complexities inherent in unraveling the truth behind high-profile cases.

6. Abducted in Plain Sight (2017)

Directed by Skye Borgman, ‘Abducted in Plain Sight’ is a documentary that unravels the shocking tale of the Broberg family, whose daughter is abducted by a cunning neighbor. The film navigates the complexities of manipulation and trust, revealing the perpetrator’s insidious tactics. With a cast composed of real-life individuals recounting their harrowing experiences, the documentary captures the vulnerability of a family torn apart by deception. Much like ‘American Nightmare,’ it underscores the unsettling reality of crimes that blur the lines between truth and manipulation, emphasizing the psychological toll on those entangled in bewildering criminal narratives.

5. The Disappearance of Madeleine McCann (2019)

In the documentary ‘The Disappearance of Madeleine McCann,’ director Chris Smith taps into the high-profile case of the young British girl who vanished during a family vacation in Portugal in 2007. The film meticulously explores the multifaceted aspects of the investigation, raising questions about the role of media scrutiny and public speculation. With a cast of involved individuals, it unveils the complexities surrounding the mysterious disappearance. Much like ‘American Nightmare,’ the documentary probes the intricacies of real-life mysteries, emphasizing the profound impact of high-profile cases on families and the broader societal fascination with unsolved crimes.

4. The Innocent Man (2018)

‘The Innocent Man’ shares thematic parallels with ‘American Nightmare’ as both documentaries expose flaws within the justice system. Directed by Ross M. Dinerstein and Clay Tweel, the series, based on John Grisham’s nonfiction book, scrutinizes two murder cases in Ada, Oklahoma, unraveling wrongful convictions and their impact on the accused. It vividly contrasts the thin line between guilt and innocence, echoing the unsettling narrative of ‘American Nightmare.’

The gripping storytelling, exploration of legal intricacies, and societal consequences in both documentaries highlight the fragility of justice. The cast includes those directly affected, enriching the narrative with personal perspectives, much like the impactful storytelling in ‘American Nightmare.’

3. Exhibit A (2019)

In ‘Exhibit AExhibit A,’ the intersection of forensic science and justice takes center stage, capturing the investigative depth seen in ‘American Nightmare.’ The series, created and directed by Kelly McPherson, dissects true crime cases and scrutinizes the reliability of forensic evidence. Through a mix of expert analysis and firsthand accounts, it shows the nitty gritty of criminal investigations and the potential pitfalls of relying solely on scientific proof.

Much like the thematic exploration in ‘American Nightmare,’ ‘Exhibit A’ prompts viewers to question the legal system’s reliance on evidence, sparking conversations about the delicate balance between truth and the unintended consequences of forensic methodologies. The series provides a compelling narrative while shedding light on the critical examination of evidence, drawing thematic parallels to the nuanced storytelling in ‘American Nightmare.’

2. Trial 4 (2020)

In the riveting true-crime docuseries ‘Trial 4,’ director Rémy Burkel uncovers the convoluted story of Sean Ellis, a man wrongfully convicted of murder in Boston. The series takes viewers on a rollercoaster journey through the twists and turns of Ellis’s legal battle, showcasing the persistence of his defense team and the murky dealings within the criminal justice system. Drawing parallels with the intense storytelling in ‘American Nightmare,’ ‘Trial 4’ captivates audiences with its exploration of systemic flaws, corruption, and the pursuit of justice. By seamlessly weaving together interviews, archival footage, and courtroom drama, the series ensnares viewers in a contemplative and emotionally charged narrative, mirroring the storytelling found in ‘American Nightmare.’

1. The Innocence Files (2020)

For enthusiasts of the gripping narrative in ‘American Nightmare,’ ‘The Innocence Files’ emerges as a must-watch odyssey into the heart of the American justice system’s intricacies. Helmed by directors Roger Ross Williams, Jed Rothstein, Sarah Dowland, Liz Garbus, Alex Gibney, and Andy Grieve—the series unfurls like a legal thriller, exposing the harrowing tales of wrongfully convicted individuals. Its meticulous exploration, akin to peeling back layers of a complex legal onion, resonates with the intricate storytelling found in ‘American Nightmare.’

The cast of real-life protagonists, including the wrongly accused and their tenacious advocates, vividly illuminate the relentless pursuit of justice. Through a blend of storytelling artistry and stark reality, ‘The Innocence Files’ offers an emotionally charged and intellectually stimulating experience that seamlessly aligns with the thematic resonance of ‘American Nightmare.’

Read More: Best Crime Movies on HBO Max