Shivangi Sinha
The 1994 O.J. Simpson murder trial remains a topic of debate and has continued to spark controversy and discussions over the years. Numerous alleged witnesses have come forward with their accounts, even if they were not part of the trial. Jill Shively is one such individual who claimed to have seen O.J. on the night of the murders. She alleged that he was much closer to the crime scene than he stated. In Netflix’s ‘American Manhunt: O.J. Simpson,’ she recounts her experience and details what she witnessed that night.
Jill Shively Alleged She Saw O.J. Simpson Near the Scene of the Murders in 1994
In 1994, Jill Shively was living in Santa Monica as a single mother to her 5-year-old daughter. On the night of June 12, she was recovering from the flu and decided to make a quick trip to the Westward Ho Market in nearby Brentwood, California, to pick up a to-go salad. She left her house just before 11 pm, and as she turned onto San Vicente Boulevard toward Bundy Drive, she claimed that a white Ford Bronco had suddenly appeared. She alleged that the vehicle had its headlights off and had just run a red light.
To avoid a collision, Shively slammed on the brakes and swerved into the next lane while the Bronco came to a stop on the median covered with grass. She recalled locking eyes with the driver and immediately feeling that he looked familiar. She suspected he might be a football player. Moments later, Shively added, she saw the man aggressively shouting at another driver, and he was urgently demanding them to move out of the way. It was then, upon hearing his voice, that she alleged that she became convinced it was O.J. Simpson. She claimed she had recently watched one of his movies and had no doubt it was him.
As the prosecution built its case, Shively was called before the grand jury, and her testimony was considered crucial. Since O.J. claimed he had been at home the night of the murders, her account placed him much closer to the crime scene around the estimated time of the killings. However, when a reporter from Hard Copy informed her that other witnesses had spoken to them and received payment, she reportedly took the opportunity as well. Unaware of the consequences, this decision ultimately led to lead prosecutor Marcia Clark dismissing her as a witness, which prevented her from testifying in court.
Jill Shively Filed a Defamation Lawsuit in the Aftermath of the O.J. Simpson Trial
In 1997, Jill Shively filed a lawsuit against Los Angeles County and her former boyfriend, Brian Patrick Clarke. She claimed that Clarke had falsely informed Deputy District Attorney Peter Bozanich in 1994 that she was on probation for a felony and, therefore, could not be a reliable witness. According to her, Bozanich then passed this information to Joseph Bosco, who later wrote a book about the case, referring to her as a “felony probationer.” The book suggested that this was the real reason for her removal from the case rather than her decision to speak to the media. However, after multiple appeals, the case was dismissed in 2003 due to Shively missing a legal deadline.
The months and years that followed were difficult for Shively. She stated that, due to the highly politicized nature of the case at the time, she faced intense media scrutiny. She even recalled an incident where a reporter attempted to take a picture through her daughter’s window. In an interview, she spoke candidly about several issues. She alleged that lead prosecutor Marcia Clark had been extremely harsh toward her after learning about her media interview. She also addressed the situation with her former boyfriend, alleging that he had personal motives and was merely trying to discredit her. However, she did acknowledge that they had a legal dispute over a credit card debt, which they eventually settled privately.
Jill Shively is Thriving in Her Career in the Insurance Industry Today
Jill Shively and her daughter eventually relocated to Woodland Hills, California. In a 2017 interview, she reflected on the guilt she had carried for giving the interview. She said she felt that it had hindered the case and that she had made a mistake. She held herself responsible for not contributing more to the investigation. However, as time passed, she reconnected with key figures involved in the case, including prosecutor Christopher Darden. When she spoke with him, he reassured her not to be so hard on herself and encouraged her to move forward with her life. When O.J. Simpson was seeking parole, Shively admitted that she felt uneasy and uncertain about what it would mean for her and her daughter.
Shively now lives in Santa Monica, California, where she works as a property claims adjuster at Mercury Insurance Group. After facing difficult years, especially during the trial when she lost her job, she is proud of how she has rebuilt her life. Her bond with her daughter remains strong, and she has cultivated a community of people who truly appreciate her. In August 2024, she celebrated 14 years of being cancer-free and has been actively contributing to and organizing fundraisers for causes like The Breast Cancer Research Foundation. Although she underwent surgery for a burn wound that same month, she is recovering well. She is politically active, vocal about her opinions, and unafraid to speak her mind. With the same determination on her face that she had years ago, she is proud of the life she has led and continues to live.
Read More: Skip Junis: What Happened to the Alleged Witness of the OJ Simpson Case?
You must be logged in to post a comment.