Kriti Mehrotra
It was back in September 1980 that the entire nation was left baffled to the very core as Kathleen O’Brien Doyle was found brutally assaulted and murdered in her Norfolk, Virginia, home. Unfortunately, though, as explored in Netflix’s ‘Into the Fire: The Lost Daughter,’ it wasn’t until nearly four decades later that her case was solved with the help of DNA evidence left behind. The technological advancements in this area were what enabled officials to connect the perpetrator to this case, following which additional details confirmed their apparent unabashed guilt.
Kathleen Doyle Was Heinously Killed Inside Her Own Bedroom
As the proud daughter of homemaker Bertha Watson O’Brien and Navy Captain John Timothy O’Brien, Kathleen was reportedly the epitome of beauty, charisma, grace, as well as intelligence. In fact, she graduated college magna cum laude with dreams of becoming a writer one day before blissfully tying the knot with the love of her life, Navy Lt. Stephen Doyle, in December 1979. But alas, little did either of them know the aspiring 25-year-old professional would lose her life on the floor of their Granby Road home’s bedroom nine months later — on September 9, 1980.
As per records, a friend of Kathleen’s had grown worried after not hearing from her for a couple of days despite them having spent a great time together on the fateful evening in the former’s home. She hence convinced her husband to drop by her place on September 11, only for them to find the house in disarray and the young woman lying naked in a pool of blood at the feet of her bed. It turns out she had been sexually assaulted, burned on the cheek with an ablaze Lincoln Log, and stabbed multiple times before being strangled to death, making it clear her death was no accident.
Kathleen Doyle’s Family Never Lost Hope For Answers
Despite the fact officials were able to recover traces of semen from Kathleen’s body as well as her bedsheet, they didn’t have much to go off on owing to a complete lack of additional evidence. There being no witnesses also didn’t help, especially since the coroner ruled she was killed sometime between 7:30 pm and midnight on September 9, shortly after her friend left to return home. As for her husband, Stephen was well accounted for since he was actually away at sea on duty onboard the USS Eisenhower — he had no idea something was even wrong until officials approached him.
Hence began Kathleen’s father’s fight to attain justice for his little girl — while Bertha and Stephen grieved, Captain John immersed himself in her case in the hopes of some concrete answers. According to the aforementioned show, he even consistently urged authorities to stay on top of it, right until he sadly passed surrounded by his loving family, yet without closure, on July 29, 2016. Other family members, particularly Kathleen’s aunt Christine Wick, then took up this mantle, only for the cold case unit to soon catch a break through technological advancements in DNA analysis.
Kathleen Doyle’s Assailant Was a Stranger
It was the semen that had been preserved from Kathleen’s bedsheets that led officials to Michigan native Dennis Bowman in 2019, just for the comparative DNA between them to be a 100% match. That’s when it came to light that this then-United States Navy Reserve member was actually in Norfolk, Virginia, in September to attend a two-week drill and that he also had a dark past. Not only had he already been convicted of assault with intent to commit criminal sexual conduct in 1980 as well as breaking and entering plus staking in 1998, but he was also a suspect in his 14-year-old adoptive daughter Aundria Bowman’s 1989 disappearance and several rapes.
Dennis was ultimately arrested in November 2019 on the charge of murder in connection with Kathleen’s cold case, only for him to ultimately confess and be sentenced to two consecutive life terms. As per his confession, he had gone to a bar and gotten blackout drunk on the evening of September 9, 1980, following which he decided to walk to his dorms even though it was really dark out. “I walk past this house,” he, who was 31 years old in 1980, told the police, per the documentary. “All the lights were out. There’s no car in the drive. And I said, ‘I wonder if they got some loose money lying around.'”
Dennis continued, “So, I went around the back of the house. I went up to a window, and (it) had a hook and latch on it. I got out a pocket knife. Opened up the window. I almost fell in the house. I was drunk… I am looking for money, all right? I went in the kitchen, and I looked into the cookie jar. Nothing there. There was another door, but when I opened the door, she sat up and started screaming. I covered her mouth with my left hand. I went to push her back down with my right. I still had that little pen knife in my hand. And when I went to push her back down, she grabbed that hand.”
Dennis then stated he stabbed Kathleen just one time when she tried to grab the weapon, but officials believe he omitted several details so as to limit his culpability despite her remains revealing everything. It’s also imperative to note he later pled no contest to second-degree murder in his adoptive daughter’s case too, so he is currently serving multiple life sentences behind bars at the age of 75.
Read More: Metta McLeod: Where is the Survivor Now?
