Shivangi Sinha
In 1988, Todd Scott was apprehended by the police in New York City after being identified as one of the individuals involved in the murder of Edward Byrne, a police officer. Byrne’s death caused widespread outrage across the nation and became a significant topic during the presidential elections of that year. In HBO’s ‘Nature of the Crime,’ Todd discussed the incident and the life he has lived since then. He reflected on his past actions and expressed that he had undergone a transformation, asserting that he was a changed man who deserved the opportunity for parole.
Todd Scott Grew Up in an Extremely Violent and Discriminatory Environment
Todd Scott was born on November 23, 1968, into a difficult and challenging life. He revealed that his mother struggled with addiction during her pregnancy, which led to him being born with a heroin addiction. Raised by his grandmother, he was still deeply affected by the social and political climate of the time. Growing up as a Black man in New York, he faced a society rife with racial tension and inequality. The city was also grappling with the rise of gang activity, which made it particularly tough for young men like Todd. The streets of New York were often controlled by gangs, and the city was experiencing economic decline, which further intensified the challenges he faced.
Todd became involved in street culture at a young age, explaining that there was no avoiding it in his environment. During that time, there was significant mistrust between minority communities and the police, fueled by systemic racism and frequent mistreatment. The tension between law enforcement and residents of New York was palpable, with many feeling targeted, oppressed, and unfairly treated by those in power. This mistrust only deepened the divide, pushing many young people, like Todd, further into the streets as they sought a sense of belonging and protection outside of traditional societal structures.
Todd Scott Distracted Officer Byrne While His Accomplice Shot Him
On February 26, 1988, around 3:30 am, 19-year-old Todd Scott, along with three other men—Philip Copeland, Scott Cobb, and David McClary—approached a police vehicle parked outside a house in the South Jamaica section of Queens, New York City. Officer Edward Byrne, just 22 years old, was stationed outside the home after it had reported illegal activities in the area. The house had previously been bombed, prompting the authorities to place Officer Byrne alone for protection. As he sat in his vehicle, Todd approached the passenger side and knocked on the window. When the officer looked away to respond, one of the other young men fired a shot, fatally wounding Officer Byrne. The four men quickly fled the scene.
The police quickly pieced together that the four men had acted under the orders of notorious drug dealer Howard “Pappy” Mason, who was incarcerated at the time. Mason’s directive for the murder was linked to a wider turf war involving his drug operations. Politically, the incident became a significant talking point, especially during the 1988 presidential elections. Byrne’s murder highlighted the growing concerns about crime, drugs, and the breakdown of law and order in New York City, as well as other major urban areas across the country. It intensified discussions on the effectiveness of law enforcement and the escalating violence in the streets, particularly within disenfranchised communities. At the time, the incident led to heightened political debate surrounding the War on Drugs, with many officials advocating for harsher sentencing laws and expanded police presence.
Todd Scott is Awaiting His Next Parole Hearing Today
Within a week of Officer Edward Byrne’s murder, Todd Scott and his accomplices were arrested. In 1989, during their trial, each of the men was handed down harsh sentences. Todd’s attorney argued that the severity of their punishments was aimed at making an example of them. He was found guilty of second-degree murder and criminal possession of a weapon despite not being the one who fired the fatal shot. He was sentenced to 25 years to life in prison. Since 2013, he has been eligible for parole, but his requests have been consistently denied.
Todd’s wife, Sabrina Scott, has been a strong advocate for his release, asserting that he is no longer the 19-year-old boy who fell victim to his circumstances. Todd himself has expressed deep regret for his actions, acknowledging the gravity of his crime. He believes he has paid a heavy price for his past mistakes and deserves a chance to reunite with his family and begin a new life. Now 56 years old, he is currently incarcerated at the Shawangunk Correctional Facility in New York State. His most recent parole appeal was denied in February 2024, with his next opportunity for parole scheduled for August 2025.
Read More: David Strickland: Where is the Killer Now?
