The usually peaceful village of Unity in Wisconsin witnessed a horrifying homicide when 58-year-old Ken Juedes was found murdered inside his own home back in 2006. One of the worst parts, though, was that the ensuing investigation saw a web of lies, deceit, and betrayal, that is, until the truth finally came to light more than 15 years later. ‘Dateline: The Trouble at Dill Creek Farm’ chronicles the same, along with how the officials ultimately apprehended and brought the accused to justice. So now, if you are intrigued by this case and wish to find out the details of all the aspects involved, we have you covered.
How Did Ken Juedes Die?
A resident of Unity, Wisconsin, Ken resided on a large 30-acre property with his wife, Cindy Schulz-Juedes. To the outside eye, their marriage appeared perfectly normal, and neighbors believed that the couple was happy with each other. Besides, Ken earned a living as a pharmacist and was known for being a kindhearted and generous soul. People who knew him insisted that Ken was always ready to extend a helping hand and make new friends, which made his murder all the more shocking.
On August 30, 2006, Ken’s wife, Cindy, approached one of their neighbors looking extremely anxious and claimed that she had found her husband lying on the bed, unresponsive, with a bloodied chest. The neighbor immediately called emergency services, and first responders arrived to declare him dead. An initial medical examination indicated gunshot wounds to his chest, just for an autopsy to later confirm that he’d been shot twice with a shotgun at close range, once in the chest and once in the back, which ultimately claimed his life.
Who Killed Ken Juedes?
The authorities did not find any signs of forced entry, and nothing seemed to be stolen from the couple’s home, but they did find a piece of paper with the word “B*tch” that had a knife driven through it. However, as they continued to thoroughly examine the entire crime scene, they were surprised to find that there were almost no signs of a possible physical altercation, which indicated that the victim knew his assailant. Still, with almost zero clues and witnesses, it wasn’t easy for law enforcement officials to come up with a list of suspects.
The initial investigation into Ken’s homicide was relatively slow as there were not a lot of leads or witnesses to work with. Although detectives canvassed the area around the home and interviewed several acquaintances, no one knew why anyone would want to hurt the 58-year-old. Yet, things took a strange turn when they talked to Ken’s wife, Cindy, for the first time. She told the police that she had an issue with noise, which forced her to spend the night of August 29 at a trailer inside their 30-acre property. Then, according to her narrative, on the morning of August 30, she was surprised not to have received any calls from her husband and decided to check up on him.
Ken was actually supposed to be on his way to work by that time, but Cindy noticed his car was still in the driveway as she made her way up to the house and believed he must have been held up by some issue or the other. Yet, she added, the moment she stepped foot into their home, she found her husband lying unresponsive on the bed in a puddle of his own blood. That was when she ran out and made her way over to a neighbor’s to ask for help.
The case initially did not witness a lot of progress in any way, shape, or form, only for the police to receive a cryptic letter with details only the killer could know around six months after the incident. Although this letter never directly led to a witness or implicated anyone, investigators did keep a close watch on Cindy and were surprised at how unperturbed she was by her husband’s death. In fact, Ken’s mother later mentioned that she’d failed to inform her about her son’s demise on that fateful morning and had only called her later in the evening. They also learned that Cindy had collected a large sum of life insurance money ($1 million) from her husband’s death and had even put up one of his properties for sale. As if that’s not enough, while her attitude made her the primary person of interest, there was the undeniable fact that her ex-husband had gifted her a shotgun that eerily matched the one used in this slaying.
However, when questioned, Cindy insisted the weapon was stolen, and she had no idea where it was, making detectives wonder why she’d never reported the theft to the police. Regardless, she kept insisting on her innocence and even offered wild theories, including one in which she claimed that a Hollywood actor could be responsible for the murder. But like in every murder case, the evidence has the last laugh, and with a mountain of the same pointing toward her as the possible killer, the police eventually arrested and charged Cindy with Ken Juedes’ death in 2019.
Once presented in court, Cindy claimed she had nothing to do with her husband’s murder and pled not guilty to the charges against her. The jury, though, did not agree with her and eventually convicted her of first-degree murder as well as a single count of resisting or obstructing an officer of the law. As a result, she was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole in June 2022.
Read More: Where Is Cindy Schulz-Juedes Now?