Aahana Swrup
Cathy Ames occupies one of the more perplexing narratives in ‘East of Eden,’ as a woman in the 19th to early 20th century with deeply complex and nuanced ambitions. She arrives at the Trask brothers’ farm, a bruised and bloodied victim of a horrifically violent attack. Although she withholds her past from Charles and even Adam, who goes on to become her husband, the narrative gives the viewers a glimpse into her early life. From an early age, Cathy was praised and coveted for her beautiful looks and her docile demeanor.
As a result, during her school years, she catches the eye of Mr. Grew, who begins to pursue her despite the indecent nature of their dynamic as a teacher and his student. Eventually, the older man dies an abrupt death. Shortly thereafter, Cathy’s own parents go up in flames in a house fire that mysteriously spares her as its victim. Across these deaths, the young girl remains a notable shared variable, which naturally casts her in a suspicious light. SPOILERS AHEAD.
Mr. Grew Comitted Suicide After a Failed Courtship With Cathy
At a young age, Cathy realizes she carries a magnetic charisma that attracts people and naturally demands attention. Moreover, her angelic looks and virtuous persona compel everyone around her to neatly tuck her into a good-girl archetype without putting in the effort to actually notice anything about her. This makes it easy for her to manipulate people for her own ulterior purposes or simple entertainment, a fact she doesn’t hesitate to exploit even as a child. Initially, it manifests in small ways, like tricking boys into gifting her small but valuable trinkets. Therefore, when Mr. Grew turns his inappropriate attention to her, she doesn’t hesitate to employ the same tricks with him. She can’t control the nature of the older man’s interest in her, but she can at least bend it to her own advantage.
Thus, Cathy gives him the impression of reciprocation and allows him to walk her home every day. Society’s propriety prevents anything substantial from blossoming between the two, but the teacher soon begins to grow restless. He is under the impression that once the young girl passes out of school, they can finally be together. Nonetheless, while Cathy enjoys toying with the man, she doesn’t wish to get tied down to him. She can handle his interest in her, but she’s scared of what he might do if he convinces himself that he’s in love. In time, his affections grow so bold that he risks detection by throwing rocks at her window at night. As such, Cathy realizes that she needs to shut down their arrangement before it turns into a wildfire of problems.
Nonetheless, Grew doesn’t take well to her rejection. After Cathy ends their relationship, he shows up at her front door at night, drunk to the point of stupid decisions. Fortunately, her father is able to get rid of him. The next morning, news of his demise arrives. As it turns out, the teacher had committed suicide by propping his gun on piles of holy books to get a clear shot at his head. Since their arrangement has been a secret, no one knows how to connect Cathy to the incident. Nonetheless, the young girl knows that Grew’s actions were likely fueled by his heartbreak. Since she never cared much about the older man and actively played a part in the manipulation that led him to his demise, she decides that she has caused his death.
Cathy Killed Her Parents as a Means to Achieve Her Liberation
Cathy’s relationship with her parents becomes the earliest demonstration of the character’s complex perception of love. Despite being an only child, she’s not very close to her parents. In her mind, her mother and father, much like the rest of the world, fail to notice anything substantial about her. They see what they want to see and then move on. However, her father notices something sinister inside of her. Her father takes note of all the times that she subtly courts the attention of young boys and men. Therefore, when Mr. Grew shoots himself to death, shortly after showing up at the family’s home drunk and asking for Cathy, the patriarch connects the dots with ease.
However, instead of being concerned about why a grown man would be pursuing his daughter, Mr. Ames remains bothered by the implication of such a connection. After hearing the news of Grew’s death, Cathy’s father whips her brutally and violently as a method of discipline. Between the beatings, he also lets her know that she’s his property and thus if she lets other men defile her, she would be ruining something that belongs to him. Therefore, the punishment becomes an act of humiliation meant to assert the father’s ownership over his daughter. Thus, Cathy realizes that if she ever wishes to be truly free in life, she needs to shed the family that is holding her down like an anchor.
Perhaps wanting her father dead is also a means of revenge for her, but her mother seems to be simple collateral damage. Cathy doesn’t wish to be tied down by anything, including love, in whatever way it may manifest. For the same reason, she comes up with a plan. First, she steals whatever money her father has in his safe. Then, she sets fire to the house, leaving her parents to burn to their deaths. Afterward, she uses chicken blood and her own belongings to stage a sign of struggle in the carriage house to give the impression that the arsonist has taken the family’s sole heir. As such, she effectively fakes her death without needing to leave behind a dead body. In the absence of her father or her mother holding her back, Cathy steps into her new life.
Read More: East of Eden: Are Adam and Charles Trask Based on Real Brothers?
You must be logged in to post a comment.