Abhiroop Das
Created by Ian Weir, the second season of Fox’s ‘Murder in a Small Town‘ is a fresh spin on the detective genre, chronicling a series of small-town mysteries through the eyes of a burnt-out city cop. Hoping to find solace in Gibsons, Karl Alberg takes on the mantle of chief of police, unaware that many cunning criminals await him, each bringing their unique brand of cases to solve. However, Karl still manages to find beauty in his new lifestyle, and that comes from the bonds he nourishes with the town community, particularly his partner, Cassandra Lee. The sophomore season of this procedural crime thriller deepens his ties with the people around him, and simultaneously ups the stakes with a new gallery of criminals added into the equation. The season finale, titled ‘Nightshade,’ explores the possibility of a serial killer who has been silently terrorizing the town for decades, until now. SPOILERS AHEAD.
Murder in a Small Town Season 2 Finale Recap
Season 2 episode 10 of ‘Murder in a Small Town,’ titled ‘Nightshade,’ begins with a man falling down the stairs in his house, following which a mysterious figure finishes the job by strangling him to death. When the police reach the scene, it is initially ruled an accident until Karl connects the strange markings on his feet to those on the staircase, indicating that someone planted a tripwire there. With a murder now on the cards, Doug’s near and dear ones are rounded up, starting with his wife, Nena, who was in an unhappy marriage with him. When nothing substantive turns out, the police widen their search, this time looking into Will’s business partner and brother, Will Raker, and their sanctuary’s veterinarian, Ella Perini. The latter appears to be particularly affected by news of Doug’s passing, while the former indicates that Nena is most likely to be the killer. Laila also learns of Doug’s previous househelp, Maeve O’ Hara, who might be connected to the mystery.
On her way out of Doug’s house, Laila finds a bouquet of enchanter’s nightshade placed at his doorstep. The pattern is consistent with the other gravesites where the flowers have been placed, and Cassandra is called into the station to confirm the same. Things are still tense between her and Karl, in large part due to his looking into her past in Sacramento without her consent. Nonetheless, with a clear indication that all of these mysterious cases are connected, the police begin to look for common patterns. At one of the pit stops, this time at Maeve O’Hara’s house, Karl learns that Nena was having an affair, and Maeve, with her background as a nun, quits the job immediately. She also presents an alibi for the night of the murder, in the form of her friend, Yvette Fraser, bringing Karl back to square one. Elsewhere, Will informs Ella that Doug was murdered, and she seemingly realizes something, which causes her to rush out in a fury.
While driving recklessly, she calls someone on the phone, declaring that she knows what crimes they have committed and that they will pay for it. This emotional buildup only serves to distract her, however, and she accidentally slams into a construction site and dies instantly. Soon, we learn that her mother is none other than Maeve, who is heartbroken to see her daughter go away. With enough clues at hand, Karl suspects that Ella and Doug were having an affair, and that might have played a role in his murder. At the same time, Laila questions Yvette, who turns out to be a former house-help for the Park family, the same as Lauren Park. Before long, the threads begin to connect, and the police find that all the deaths connected by the nightshade plant are also connected by Maeve’s involvement, one way or another.
With a suspect now in sight, Karl narrows the search down further, but realizes that Maeve is already gone from her house. At the same time, he confirms that Yvette lied in her alibi, which adds all the more credence to her friend being the lead suspect. Elsewhere, at the Gibsons library, Holly sets up her grand exhibition, featuring photos from the many gravesites that were visited by the nightshade creeper. On top of that, she also does some amateur sleuth work, much to Cassandra’s distress. As it turns out, no active botanical gardens or plants raise or sell the nightshade flower, but one in particular, named Lunsford Farms, may be the exception. Although Cassandra directs Karl’s two daughters not to visit the place, she soon finds them missing and assumes the worst. With Karl not picking up his phone, she decides to head to the place herself, simmering the plot to a climax.
Murder in a Small Town Season 2 Ending: Does Cassandra Say Yes to Marrying Karl?
‘Murder in a Small Town’ season 2 episode 10 ends with a cliffhanger, awaiting Cassandra’s reply to Karl’s marriage proposal. This comes after several episodes of buildup, with Karl looking for the right moment to ask her this question. However, with the credits rolling right before Cassandra speaks, her exact response cannot be determined just yet. This is likely an intentional decision on the creators’ end, calling on the audience’s understanding of the love story to predict its next course. Based on the fact that Karl’s proposal is preceded by the couple opening up to each other in a heartfelt conversation, the chances of Cassandra saying yes to the marriage are quite high. At the same time, the nuances of that same conversation reveal that the next chapter in their relationship might be far more complicated than either of them realizes.
Karl’s marriage proposal is set up in the penultimate episode of the season, when his daughter, Holly, finds the ring he has been saving for the special occasion. Although the scene indicates that he has a grand plan in mind, the actual proposal in this episode takes the form of a warm, close-knit conversation instead. After an emotionally challenging day, Cassandra sits down with her partner to discuss how they have just begun scratching the surface of their relationship. To that end, they decide to reveal secrets about themselves as a trust-building exercise. An important detail here is that, despite opening up about his father, Karl still hesitates to release too much information, and instead hastily jumps onto the proposal. As such, despite the question itself coming out of the bottom of his heart, its placement in the larger narrative reflects Karl’s tendency to hide things about himself, even from the person he loves the most.
Although Cassandra is most likely to say yes to Karl’s proposal, her conversations with him thus far point to several hidden layers in their relationship. While they have a passionate love life, there are still visible gaps in their understanding of each other, and that becomes the source of all relationship troubles that we encounter in this season. Most notably, Karl’s intrusion into her personal life, particularly into her past with Warren, can be interpreted as their dynamic still having a long way to go. As such, it is possible that she does not feel ready for marriage just yet and might need some more time to mull over it. However, what remains unchanged is the fact that they love each other, and that is evident in how Cassandra describes her six months with him as the best six months of her life. Thus, while the proposal puts the duo’s bond to the test, their feelings for each other are unlikely to change.
Who Killed Doug Bodanski, Lauren Park, and the Others? Why?
While Cassandra’s reply to Karl’s proposal is left ambiguous, the season finale puts a definitive full stop to the mystery of the Nightshade murders. First introduced in episode 3, the mysterious “Creeper” is known for visiting Lauren Park’s grave every month, where they place flowers known as the enchanter’s nightshade. Where this becomes trickier, however, is when Cassandra discovers the same flowers at the grave of a man named Trescott. Before long, a few more names pop up, all connected by their sudden and odd manners of death. Lauren Park, for instance, died in a hit-and-run, whereas Trescott fell off a hill. When the same flowers are found at the house of Doug Bodanski, moments after his murder, the connection becomes more than apparent. In the end, Lauren Park and Doug Bodanski’s murderer, AKA the Nightshade killer, turns out to be Maeve O’Hara, Doug’s former housekeeper.
Initially, all of Maeve’s murders appear to be unlinked, but her driving force is ultimately revealed to be psychological, wherein she identifies people as sinners. In the case of Lauren Park, a high school student, we learn that she seemingly lied to her mother about stealing money, and pinned the blame on their then house-help, Yvette Fraser. Maeve, who was friends with Yvette, was infuriated by that lie to the point of killing Lauren Park. From there, all her murders follow a similar pattern, with adultery likely being the reason she killed Doug. Although she had quit as his house helper some time prior, her daughter, Ella Perini, was in love with him. Although it is not confirmed whether Doug had an affair, Maeve possibly believed that to be the case, leading her to murder him in cold blood. While all of her previous crimes flew under the radar, Karl and Cassandra’s combined might connect the missing dots and solve the case.
Notably, it is Cassandra, not Karl, who manages to track Maeve first, even if it is purely by accident. After locating a botanical garden named Lunsford Farms with the help of Karl’s daughters, Cassandra initially plans to keep the mystery on a back burner, but is forced to head there herself when she loses contact with Holly. As fate would have it, Holly’s phone simply died, and now Cassandra finds herself face to face with Maeve of all people, completely unaware of her true identity. Immediately, she asks about enchanter’s nightshade, as the flower’s symbolic association with vengeance means a potential connection to the killer. Maeve understands that as well and prepares to attack Cassandra, but is stopped just in time by Karl and his team. Although we never get an exact pin on Maeve’s total kill count. She is undoubtedly a serial killer on par with Tommy Cummins, cementing herself as one of the fiercest criminals that the Sunshine Coast has ever seen.
Is Laila Sober Again? Will She and Vanessa Get Back Together?
Although the previous episode ends on a sour note for Laila and her relationship with Vanessa, the finale brings forth the possibility of things brightening up for both of them. Before the final sequence with Karl and Cassandra, we wrap up Laila’s arc for the season with her declaring that she is nearly one day sober. This comes as a powerful moment in her arc, as just last episode, she broke what appears to be a three-year streak of being alcohol free. As such, within a single episode, we see her lifting up from one of the darkest points in her life to a hopeful one. Although the details around her alcohol addiction are still blurry to an extent, a fresh start means that we might get deeper insight into her life soon. To that end, Laila’s conclusion widens the thematic scope of the ending, continuing the trend of people trying to better themselves via communication with their loved ones.
While Laila is officially back on track with regard to her recovery from addiction, it still appears that her love story with Vanessa has come to a close. In the end, Laila realizes the fault in her attitude and apologizes to Vanessa. However, neither brings up the possibility of getting back together, showing that it is still a sensitive subject for the former couple. Still, as both of them visibly care for each other, it is possible that they might reconcile their differences and get back together as a pair. The same trend holds for Sid and his daughter Liza, who is similarly dealing with an alcohol addiction. As such, the finale of season 2 compiles every grand and subtle development over the course of its ten-episode run, and presents a therapeutic narrative where love and community restore peace in the town of Gibsons, even if for a moment.
You must be logged in to post a comment.