Kriti MehrotraNBC’s ‘Dateline: Abducted’ and Netflix’s ‘Stolen Baby: The Murder of Heidi Broussard’ profile the 2019 disappearance and demise of Heidi Broussard, which sparked a search, the results of which left everyone confounded. After all, her two-week-old newborn, Margo Carey, had also vanished along with her, only to be recovered from the home of one of Heidi’s best friends, Magen Rose Fieramusca. However, in the trunk of Magen’s car, parked outside her Houston-area residence, Heidi’s body was also found. Thus, of course, she was indicted for being a killer.
Magen Fieramusca Desperately Wanted a Baby to Raise
Magen Rose Fieramusca and Heidi Broussard met at a church camp when they were 11-years-old, where they instantly formed a bond and never let go. From going through relationships and tough times as teens to starting a family and considering work changes in their 20s and early 30s, they always stuck by each other. Magen was in the delivery room with Heidi when she welcomed both her children into this world, most recently on November 26, 2019 (for her daughter Margo). Magen had driven to Austin even though she claimed she was 37 weeks pregnant herself.
Both Magen and Heidi had announced their pregnancies around the same time in 2019 and had excitedly spoken about possibly giving birth on the same day. Despite having broken up in March 2019, Magen and her partner, Christoper Green, had continued to live together at the 8100 block of Bo Jack Drive in Houston for their future child. He genuinely believed he was going to be a father because Magen not only claimed she was pregnant, but her belly was also growing over time. He never saw it bare as they were no longer romantically involved, but he did describe it as “hard” when officials eventually asked him about it in Decmber.
Moreover, per Heidi’s fiancé, Shane Carey, Magen had acted strangely after Margo came into this world. In fact, he told officials, she had intervened when the paternal grandfather was given the baby to hold, saying she wanted to be first because she had to leave soon. Then, he revealed he had handed Magen a set of keys to the residence he shared with Heidi so that she could stay the night and relax before heading home, but he never got them back. According to surveillance cameras at this apartment complex, on December 12, 2019, Magen’s light gray Nissan Versa was in the area, which was then corroborated by her cell phone pings.
As if all this wasn’t enough, a witness saw a woman leaving with a baby wearing a knit cap in her arms that same morning. Furthermore, Magen’s online footprint implicated her. That evening, after 10:30 p.m., she’d looked up “reasons for Amber Alert” and “Amber Alert issued Austin.” Then, two days later, she’d searched “bodies found in Austin, Texas” before deleting her Facebook account for good on December 17, 2019. The worst of all was that Magen had looked up Heidi’s name online about 162 times in a month, making it seem like she was obsessed with her friend. In the end, even FBI behavioral analysts concluded that Magen was driven by a desperate compulsion to have a child.
Magen Fieramusca is Incarcerated at the William P. Hobby Unit
Magen was arrested at her home in December 2019, around a week after Heidi’s remains were recovered from her car, and Margo was found in her care. She was subsequently charged with two counts of third-degree kidnapping (for Heidi and Margo), one count of tampering with a body, and one count of capital murder in connection with Heidi’s homicide. The 2-week postpartum mother had been strangled to death. It eventually came to light that Magen faked her entire pregnancy with the intention of stealing Heidi’s newborn and passing it off as her own. As per records, Heidi had told Shane that Magen delivered a girl on December 8 or 9, yet in her official interrogation, Magen stated it was on the 12th.
Therefore, upon remaining in jail on a $1.6 million bond for over three years due to the pandemic, Magen pleaded guilty to just one count of first-degree murder on February 2, 2023. She was consequently sentenced to 55 years behind bars. It’s actually imperative to note that, as per her plea agreement, she has waived her right to appeal, meaning her cases stopped being viable for any sort of post-conviction litigation following the final sentencing hearing.
Hence, today, at the age of 40, Magen Rose Fieramusca is incarcerated at the maximum-security William P. Hobby Unit for women in Marlin, Falls County, Texas, where she’s expected to remain until at least 2047. We say this because, according to the State Department of Corrections’ official records, her full term ends on December 18, 2074, but she will become eligible for parole on June 19, 2047.
Read More: Where is Shane Carey Now?
You must be logged in to post a comment.