Abhiroop Das
Helmed by Shana Feste, Netflix’s ‘Heartland’ follows a former country singer named Misty Jones as she returns to her hometown to search for her missing niece. Charlie Heart, a country star herself, seems to have disappeared without telling anyone, and when Misty discovers blood strewn in the apartment, she naturally fears the worst. Carrying out an amateur investigation in the underbelly of Nashville, however, proves to be much more difficult than she expected, and in the process, Misty encounters many eccentric people, many of whom have the individual pieces that can make the puzzle whole. By the end of this western mystery movie, Misty comes to learn a lot about not just Charlie’s life, but also about herself. SPOILERS AHEAD.
Heartland Plot Synopsis
‘Heartland’ begins with Misty Jones, a disgraced former country musician returning to her hometown in Nashville, only for things to look remarkably different. The music scene has become even more commercialized than before, and with hardly any friends left, she naturally spends most of her time alone. This changes when her brother, Donny, arrives with the news that his daughter, the pop country star Charlie Heart, has gone missing. While she is usually known to dip out of the public and return a while later, something about this time feels different. Another reason Donny asks for his sister’s help, though, is because he isn’t Charlie’s biological parent, and her real mother is none other than Misty herself.
As Misty goes out to her regular group of watering holes asking questions, she soon runs into her ex-husband and Charlie’s biological dad, Clark Allen West. The two of them ended things on a sour note, and this conversation doesn’t help much either. Next up, she encounters Roy Combs, Charlie’s manager and the local music kingpin, who also seems to be struggling to locate her. The most obvious suspect appears to be one of Charlie’s stalkers, Jared Granger, though the police don’t find anything at his apartment. As the investigation begins to cool down, Misty takes it upon herself to break into Charlie’s house, only to discover blood on the carpet and clear signs of a struggle, suggesting that something terrible went down.
As the investigation takes a completely new turn, Misty decides to go public with the fact that she is Charlie’s biological mother. Talking to Roy later, she explains that, back then, she and Clark didn’t think they were fit to be parents, but now the time seems to have come for her to own up to this responsibility. After digging into some of the details and asking some questions, Misty makes a break when she discovers that Jared has a second home. While Charlie is nowhere to be found there, Misty does end up with her bloodied clothes. As Jared gets arrested and the case seems to be reaching its climax, Misty makes a connection between a piece of scrap paper she found in her daughter’s room and horse betting numbers, which suggests that the real culprit is Roy Combs himself. Before she can take any action, though, Charlie shows up at her doorstep, flipping the board upside down.
Heartland Ending: Is Charlie Found? Does She Live or Die?
‘Heartland’ ends with Misty reuniting with Charlie and personally putting an end to her troubles, starting with Roy Combs. While all the clues surrounding Charlie’s disappearance initially point towards foul play, that in itself turns out to be a piece of misdirection, expertly planted by Charlie herself. Knowing that no one would suspect her absence for at least a few days, she constructs an elaborate image, complete with blood on the carpet and false evidence that leads nowhere. All of this is so that she can go into a hideout and let others presume her death, likely forever. While this doesn’t exactly make for a lifetime solution, the fact that Charlie went to such lengths speaks to how desperate she must have been, and it takes a while for Misty, and by extension us, to realize the full truth.
Charlie’s decision to run away and hide came as a last, despair-driven attempt to escape Roy’s clutches, as he was hell-bent on exploiting her for money. While we are told early on that Roy has racked up quite the debt, things only begin to add up when Misty realizes that the piece of paper with numbers on it, that she found in Charlie’s room, wasn’t a code but lottery numbers. Roy, as it turns out, paid the house a visit after the disappearance, only to similarly assume that she had been killed. The reason Charlie specifically fakes her death is that it leaves Roy with no leverage, whereas he was earlier relying on compromising pictures of her that he took when she was a minor.
The reveal about the abuse Charlie had to endure puts a new light on her meetings with her biological parents in the weeks prior to her disappearance. While both Misty and Clark think of this reunion as a difficult, awkward conversation that they’d rather avoid, in retrospect it can be interpreted as Charlie’s last plea for help. However, with Misty eventually locating her and coming to understand the bigger picture, the dynamics shift entirely. It doesn’t take long for Misty to go primal and essentially bait Roy into revealing his true colors. The moment he does so, the scene turns into a good old western showdown, except, instead of standing off with a pistol, Roy decides to attack with his car. After a nail-biting exchange, Misty nonetheless emerges as victorious and seizes the laptop before passing the torch onto her daughter.
Does Roy go to Prison?
While Roy narrowly manages to survive the car showdown, that is revealed to be a part of Misty’s design. Her real goal is to have the truth unmasked in front of the entire world, and for Roy to face the law. However, the choice to do any of that ultimately doesn’t rest with her, but rather with Charlie. After getting the laptop, as well as Roy’s cut-off thumb to access it, Charlie is faced with a new dilemma: either to erase all the pictures and bury the entire incident, or actually bring them to the police and press charges against the man who has been abusing her for years. This becomes an even more challenging call when she discovers that he had pictures of other girls as well, as now the option of going public is something that will have to be collectively decided.
Instead of trying to influence Charlie’s decision, or force her into one, Misty leaves her be, perhaps consciously rejecting the cycle that got them to this place in the first place. While Charlie has a path that can make this entire ordeal disappear with a click, she also holds the ability to bring the other survivors together and make Roy pay. In the end, she decides to do the latter and, together with the other girls, reveals the truth on national television. Roy is promptly arrested upon discharge, and while we don’t see the trial play out or hear the results, it is very much implied that Roy is found guilty and sentenced. With that, a huge contributor to this toxic system is brought to his knees, and it is a decision that has a strong, positive ripple effect.
In a way, a lot of ‘Heartland’ is about unveiling the many forms of abuse that are often swept under the rug, as is the case for Misty’s former music partner, Winnie Jo Lean. While it is believed that the two parted ways due to Misty’s jealousy-fueled turn to violence, Winnie reveals that she was actually attacked by her ex-husband before a major event, and allowed Misty to take the fall. By the end of the film, though, Winnie too feels empowered to come out with the truth, much like Charlie. As more and more women begin to raise their voice, a systemic overhaul seems to be on the horizon, vindicating Misty in the process.
Will Misty Become a Singer Again?
With Misty making a grand return to the big stage in the final set piece of the film, if only to distract Roy, a big question emerges about her future. It’s apparent that her voice hasn’t lost its magic or finesse one bit, and with people clearly eager to hear more, there is a chance for Misty to return to the world of music. While she does end up behind bars in the aftermath of the showdown with Roy, the sentence isn’t a very long one, and Charlie doesn’t waste any time in proposing a musical comeback. To her surprise, however, Misty turns down the offer, explaining that her time in the spotlight has already reached its end. While Misty’s love for country music never wavered, somewhere along the lines she began to detest the toxic structure surrounding the industry, and it’s this very structure that she ultimately rejects.
Misty’s decision to reject the offer also has a second, more symbolic layer, as it marks a transition from the old to the young. While country music is typically celebrated for its approach to nostalgia, family, and the community spirit, all of those things seem to be missing from Misty’s own life. More specifically, it’s the slow, painful shedding away of happiness that leaves her in such a bitter mindset, not just about music, but life in general. However, in the process of looking for her daughter and coming to truly care for her, Misty’s buried emotions begin to emerge once again, breathing life into her songs of nostalgia, be it “Those Family Ties” or “Heartland.” Except this time, these songs signify a call for future memories to be made and cherished, through none other than Charlie.
After making peace with her daughter, Misty realizes that there is still one big piece of the puzzle that’s left to address. Accordingly, she makes her way to Frank, only to find him in the same bathtub that keeps haunting her memories. This entire time, the bathtub appears as a symbol of everything she cherished about their relationship, and how it all withered away; thus, its physical reappearance creates room for things to change. After years of radio silence, the duo decides to finally have a heart-to-heart about their past, present, and future. Perhaps most importantly, both of them embrace the pride that comes with being Charlie’s parents, and while it’s unlikely that they will ever be romantically linked again, this connection suggests that things are starting to look brighter and warmer in Misty’s life, bit by bit.
Read More: Is The Body a True Story? Is The Lions Based on a Real Dance Group?
You must be logged in to post a comment.